FREE SHIPPING on orders of $250 or more in the continental U.S.

Yes you CAN eat oysters year-round, and you should!

Yes you CAN eat oysters year-round, and you should!
Photo Credit: Boe Marsh, Community Shellfish, Bremen, ME

Can you eat oysters in months without an “R” in them?

YES!

Has anyone ever told you not to eat raw oysters months that don’t have an r in them? Did you wonder if that was true?

The truth is you CAN eat oysters year round, including May, June July and August.  But not so long ago, avoiding them during summer months was a pretty good idea, and there are a few reasons:

1.) The first one’s pretty obvious: unless you live right on the water, oysters need to get from the coast to you.  And before modern refrigeration, that posed a challenge, though not as much as you might think. 

Because oysters evolved to live in the intertidal zone where they’re exposed at low tide, they’re able to slow their metabolism and keep their shells VERY tightly closed when they’re out of water.  Please note I’m talking here about the Eastern Oyster, Crassostrea virginica, which dominates the US market.  Belon Oysters, aka the European Flat Oyster, have flatter shells and can’t stay as tightly closed, which is why they’re often stored with elastics (elastic = Maine speak for rubber band) around them.  Their shelf life is considerably less than Eastern Oysters, but personally I’m OK with that, because I find eating a Belon oyster unpleasantly similar to sucking on a blood covered penny. But back to my story...

Chances are your ancestors ate a LOT more (Eastern) oysters than you do, because they were an uncommonly transportable form of protein.  Oysters traveled far from the coast, packed in barrels, baskets or crates lined with seaweed to keep them moist.  But here's the thing: they could only travel during the cooler months:  while oysters can survive for weeks out of water if kept cold and moist, they get very nasty very quickly when exposed to hot or dry conditions.  

Fun Fact: In the 1800’s, oysters were a common bar food, given out for free to encourage the purchase of drinks.  NY harbor held an immense supply of oysters, with some scientists speculating it once held HALF the population of the world’s oysters.  Historians estimate the average NYC resident ate between 600 and 900 oysters per year in the 1800’s.


2.) Oysters spawn in the summer, and as they prepare to spawn, they devote almost all their energy to reproduction. Unlike most other animals, oysters don't have permanently distinct reproductive organs. Instead, much of their soft tissue develops into reproductive tissue (gonads) during the spawning season.  Adult oysters spend most of the year getting ready to spawn, eating and storing energy in the form of glycogen. Glycogen is basically glucose in storage form. When it comes time to spawn, that stored glycogen is either turned into gonads or used to fuel that transformation.  When they spawn, both males and females lose between 20 and 40% of their body mass (you think YOU get tired after sex?!).  And because that little oyster just gave its all, it’s tuckered out, withered, and often slightly transparent: not the ideal oyster.

This is why most growers now grow specially bred “triploid” oysters, which have three sets of chromosomes and are therefore sterile.  That means all the energy that would have gone to reproduction can be devoted to growing (think of how productive a monk is compared to a teenage boy!). Triploids grow faster, they can grow bigger and since they don’t spawn they can be sold year-round.  Most farm-raised oysters in the US – likely around 2/3 nationwide but closer to 90% on the west coast, are triploids.

·      Oysters that DO spawn are plumpest right before they spawn, but because glycogen (which was stored glucose) is transformed into eggs and sperm, they lose some of their sweetness. So those nice, fat oysters may not always be the best.

3.) Lastly, Biotoxins: Have you heard of “red tide”?  A red tide is just one type of harmful algal bloom.  Most algae is harmless, but there are certain types that aren’t. When light, nutrients, and temperature conditions are right, these algae reproduce rapidly. Oysters are filter feeders, pumping 20-50 gallons of water across their gills daily to filter out their food. As a result, they’re sucking up lots of this algae.  As the algae is broken down by digestion, nutrients are absorbed and the toxins are accumulated in the digestive gland. Oddly, these toxins don’t harm the oyster, but they can do a lot of damage to humans if we eat them. Three main types of toxins are produced by different algae: paralytic toxins, amnesic and diarrhetic, and trust me when I say you don't want to mess with any of them: they can make humans very sick and can even be lethal.

If this is making you nervous, DON’T PANIC! Because the National Shellfish Sanitation Program has established rigorous protocols and testing programs to make sure you don’t have to worry when you eat your oysters!  In fact the only confirmed fatalities from eating shellfish containing these sorts of toxins come from recreationally harvested shellfish, meaning people that harvested their own shellfish, bypassing the testing protocols set up to ensure safety.  

In addition to biotoxins from algae, other potentially harmful critters (if you can call bacteria critters, and I do) are more common in warm summer months because like many organisms, warmth and sunshine fuel growth.  But again, as with biotoxins, coastal states have rigorous refrigeration and icing protocols to keep you safe.

·       Fun fact: Research from Nicole Cannarozzi and Michal Kowalewski  at the Florida Museum of Natural History suggest folks were avoiding summer oysters as far back as 4,000 years ago. They know this because in examining shell middens (mounds of discarded oyster shells) they found many oyster shells contained a species of microscopic snail that only lives one year.  By measuring the growth rings on these snails, they were able to figure out that NONE of the oysters in those middens were harvested in the summer. Pretty cool, huh?

·      Until recently, biotoxin testing involved injecting bits of shellfish tissue into the abdominal cavities of mice and then waiting to see how long it took them to die: the amount of time it took was an indicator for the toxic load.  Thankfully, in the early part of this century, this practice began to be phased out in favor of liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry, which is far more precise, identifies the exact form of toxin, and doesn’t involve killing mice.

So what does this all mean?  It means the oysters you buy at your local fishmonger or restaurant have passed through a very controlled, rigorous testing protocol.  You can eat them year round, and you absolutely should!  I occasionally offer oysters from Emily's Oysters, Community Shellfish and other purveyors, but there are plenty of folks in Maine who specialize in oysters and can sell you all sorts of varieties.  So grab an oyster knife and start shucking, or take the easy route: head to your local oyster bar.  Enjoy!

Previous blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published